Healthiest Frozen Pizza: 8 Brands Compared by the Label

What is the healthiest frozen pizza? 8 brands compared per serving and per whole pizza: calories, protein, sodium, saturated fat and additives.

By NutriSmart Team9 min read

The title Healthiest Frozen Pizza above a box labeled Frozen Pizza with a veggie pizza pictured on it, a baked thin crust slice topped with spinach, mushrooms and red peppers, and three cherry tomatoes

Frozen pizza is the easiest dinner in the freezer. But the boxes are very different inside – in salt, protein and additives.

The short answer: the healthiest frozen pizza is a cheese or veggie pizza. Look for about 700 mg of sodium or less per serving and a short ingredient list. Among popular brands, Caulipower Margherita and Amy’s Margherita come out best. Banza has the most fiber. Big pepperoni pizzas like DiGiorno, Red Baron and Screamin’ Sicilian have the most salt per pizza. Their pepperoni, like Totino’s, also contains BHA, BHT and sodium nitrite.

8 frozen pizzas compared per serving

Each box decides what “one serving” is. It can be 1/6 of the pizza or 1/2 of it. So check the serving size first.

Pizza Serving Calories Protein Sodium Sat. fat
Caulipower Margherita 1/2 pizza 370 13 g 590 mg 5 g
Amy’s Margherita 1/3 pizza 280 11 g 530 mg 4.5 g
Banza Four Cheese (chickpea crust) 1/2 pizza 420 17 g 680 mg 10 g
Newman’s Own Thin & Crispy Uncured Pepperoni 1/3 pizza 340 15 g 870 mg 7 g
Screamin’ Sicilian Holy Pepperoni 1/5 pizza 330 14 g 660 mg 8 g
DiGiorno Rising Crust Pepperoni 1/6 pizza 300 15 g 750 mg 5 g
Red Baron Classic Crust Pepperoni 1/4 pizza 380 15 g 800 mg 9 g
Totino’s Party Pizza Pepperoni 1/2 pizza 360 9 g 740 mg 8 g

Labels from the brands’ websites (Caulipower, Amy’s, Banza, Screamin’ Sicilian, Red Baron, Totino’s) and Open Food Facts for DiGiorno and Newman’s Own, checked November 2026. Recipes change – check the box.

Per serving, the pizzas look close. But a 1/6 serving is much smaller than a 1/2 serving. Most people eat more than one serving, too.

The same pizzas per whole pizza

Pizza Servings per box Calories Protein Sodium Sat. fat
Caulipower Margherita 2 740 26 g 1,180 mg 11 g
Amy’s Margherita 3 840 32 g 1,590 mg 13 g
Banza Four Cheese 2 840 34 g 1,360 mg 20 g
Totino’s Party Pizza Pepperoni 2 720 17 g 1,480 mg 16 g
Newman’s Own Uncured Pepperoni 3 about 1,020 about 45 g about 2,610 mg about 21 g
Red Baron Classic Crust Pepperoni 4 about 1,520 about 60 g about 3,200 mg about 36 g
Screamin’ Sicilian Holy Pepperoni 5 about 1,650 about 70 g about 3,300 mg about 40 g
DiGiorno Rising Crust Pepperoni 6 about 1,800 about 90 g about 4,500 mg about 30 g

Caulipower, Amy’s, Banza and Totino’s print whole-pizza values on the label. For the others, we multiplied one serving by the number of servings, so the totals are “about”.

Salt is the big problem. Adults should eat less than 2,300 mg of sodium a day. A whole DiGiorno has about twice that. In a study of what Americans eat, pizza was the number one source of sodium (Ahmed et al., Nutrients, 2023).

Less salt really helps. In one trial, 412 adults ate diets with high, medium and low salt for a month each. Blood pressure went down as salt went down. This worked in people with and without high blood pressure (Sacks et al., New England Journal of Medicine, 2001).

Protein differs too. Totino’s has only 17 g of protein in 720 calories. Its “cheese” is mostly an imitation cheese made from water, vegetable oil and starches. The others give you about 3.5–5 g of protein per 100 calories.

The best picks, one by one

Caulipower Margherita – least sodium

The crust is made from cauliflower, rice flour, starches and egg. There are no preservatives. A whole pizza has 740 calories and 1,180 mg of sodium – the lowest in our list. The downside: only 6 g of fiber and 26 g of protein in the whole pizza. And “cauliflower crust” doesn’t mean low calorie. Half a pizza still has 370 calories.

Amy’s Margherita – shortest ingredient list

Amy’s uses organic wheat flour, organic tomatoes, whole milk mozzarella, olive oil, parmesan and basil. There are no preservatives or dough conditioners. One third of the pizza has 280 calories and 530 mg of sodium. It’s a regular white-flour crust, so fiber is low (5 g in the whole pizza).

Banza Four Cheese – most fiber

Banza’s crust is made mostly from chickpeas. Half a pizza has 10 g of fiber and 17 g of protein. That’s more fiber than any other pizza here, and the most protein of the cheese pizzas. The catch: 10 g of saturated fat per half. That’s half a day’s limit. It comes from four cheeses and cocoa butter in the crust.

Newman’s Own Uncured Pepperoni – the pepperoni pick

If you want pepperoni, this one has no BHA or BHT. The pepperoni is cured with celery powder and sea salt, not sodium nitrite. But “uncured” doesn’t mean nitrite-free. Celery powder is rich in nitrate, which turns into nitrite – the same compound. Read more in our guide to nitrates in food. It’s also salty: 870 mg of sodium per serving, the most per serving in our list.

The classic pepperoni pizzas

DiGiorno, Red Baron, Screamin’ Sicilian and Totino’s all use pepperoni with sodium nitrite, BHA and BHT. Some add more:

  • Totino’s: imitation mozzarella, titanium dioxide (a white color), TBHQ (a preservative) and L-cysteine (a dough conditioner).
  • Red Baron: palm oil and dough conditioners that may include ammonium sulfate and L-cysteine.
  • DiGiorno: DATEM, an emulsifier (it helps fat and water mix) that makes dough stronger.

Trader Joe’s and Real Good Foods were on our list too. We couldn’t check current Trader Joe’s labels online, so they aren’t in the table. Real Good Foods no longer shows pizza on its website.

The additives in frozen pizza

BHA and BHT in pepperoni

BHA and BHT are preservatives. They stop the fat in pepperoni from going rancid (stale and bad-smelling).

BHA has a warning sign from animal studies. Rats ate BHA as 0.5% or 2% of their food for two years. The higher dose caused tumors and cancer in the forestomach (Ito et al., Journal of the National Cancer Institute, 1983). In another study, hamsters ate food with 1–2% BHA for 24 weeks. They all grew small tumors in the forestomach (Ito et al., Gann, 1983).

Humans don’t have a forestomach. And these doses are far higher than what’s in a pizza. Still, animal studies matter. Rodents share most of our genes and body processes. Testing a possible cancer cause on people would put their health at risk.

The WHO’s cancer agency calls BHA “possibly carcinogenic to humans”. The US National Toxicology Program says it is “reasonably anticipated” to cause cancer. In February 2026, the FDA started a new safety review of BHA. Proof of harm in people is missing. But tumors showed up in more than one animal species. So it makes sense to limit BHA as a precaution.

Sodium nitrite and processed meat

Pepperoni is a processed meat. Experts reviewed over 800 studies for the WHO. Each 50 g of processed meat a day (about two slices of ham) raised the risk of colorectal cancer by about 18%. That’s cancer of the colon or rectum (Bouvard et al., Lancet Oncology, 2015).

Nitrite from additives is one suspected reason. A French study followed 101,056 adults. Those who got the most nitrite from food additives had more prostate cancer (Chazelas et al., International Journal of Epidemiology, 2022). In 104,168 adults from the same study, more additive nitrite was linked to more type 2 diabetes (Srour et al., PLOS Medicine, 2023). These studies show links, not proof. But they point the same way.

Dough conditioners

Dough conditioners make dough stronger and easier to shape by machine. The ones in these pizzas include ascorbic acid (vitamin C), enzymes, DATEM, L-cysteine and ammonium sulfate. Vitamin C and enzymes are of little concern. None of the 8 pizzas lists the more debated potassium bromate or azodicarbonamide.

Titanium dioxide in imitation cheese

Totino’s uses titanium dioxide to make its imitation cheese white. In 2021, European food safety experts said it could no longer be considered safe. They couldn’t rule out damage to DNA (the genes inside our cells). The EU banned it in food in 2022. It is still allowed in the US.

How to choose a healthier frozen pizza: 6 checks

Check Aim for Why
Sodium About 700 mg or less per serving Whole pizzas range from 1,180 to 4,500 mg
Serving size Compare the same share Boxes split a pizza 2 to 6 ways
Protein 10 g or more per serving Keeps you full longer – add a side of chicken or beans if it’s low
Saturated fat 5 g or less per serving Cheese and pepperoni pizzas reach 8–10 g
Toppings Cheese or vegetables Pepperoni adds salt, nitrite, BHA and BHT
Ingredient list Short, with real foods Fewer conditioners, preservatives and imitation cheese

Most frozen pizzas are ultra-processed foods. In a strict hospital study, 20 adults could eat as much as they wanted. On an ultra-processed diet, they ate about 500 more calories a day than on simple foods (Hall et al., Cell Metabolism, 2019). That’s why the shortest ingredient list usually wins.

For other freezer foods, like bowls, burritos and plain vegetables, see our guide to healthy frozen meals.

Make any frozen pizza better: add vegetables

  1. Top it before baking. Add a handful of spinach, sliced mushrooms or peppers. Per 3.5 oz (100 g), raw spinach has 23 calories, mushrooms 22 and red peppers 26 (USDA). Frozen vegetables work too – thaw and pat them dry first.
  2. Eat a salad first. In one study, 42 women ate a big, light salad before a pasta lunch. They ate 12% fewer calories at that meal (Rolls et al., Journal of the American Dietetic Association, 2004).
  3. Plate one or two servings. Put the rest away before you sit down.
  4. Count it. See how many calories are in a slice of pizza. Then use our calorie calculator to see how pizza fits your day.

Compare frozen pizzas in the store. With NutriSmart, you photograph the label or scan the barcode. The app lists the preservatives, colors and other additives, explains the risks of each one and gives the pizza a health score out of 100. It also tells you right away if a pizza is ultra-processed and which ingredients make it so. You can even set an alert for BHA or sodium nitrite – the app warns you whenever a scanned product contains it.Get the app free

The bottom line

The healthiest frozen pizza is a cheese or veggie pizza. Look for about 700 mg of sodium or less per serving and a short ingredient list. Among popular brands, Caulipower Margherita and Amy’s Margherita come out best. Banza has the most fiber. Big pepperoni pizzas from DiGiorno, Red Baron and Screamin’ Sicilian have the most salt per pizza. Their pepperoni, like Totino’s, also has BHA, BHT and sodium nitrite. Whatever you buy, eat one or two servings, add vegetables and have a salad on the side.

FAQ

What is the healthiest frozen pizza?

Among popular brands, Caulipower Margherita and Amy's Margherita come out best. A whole pizza has about 740–840 calories and 1,180–1,590 mg of sodium. Both have a short ingredient list and no pepperoni preservatives. Banza Four Cheese has the most fiber, but more saturated fat.

Is frozen pizza bad for you?

Not as an occasional meal. The problem is salt and portion size. A whole pepperoni pizza can have up to 4,500 mg of sodium. That's about twice the daily limit of 2,300 mg. Eat one or two servings and add vegetables.

Which frozen pizza has the least sodium?

In our comparison, Caulipower Margherita had the least per whole pizza: 1,180 mg, or 590 mg per half. Cheese and veggie pizzas usually have less salt than pepperoni or meat pizzas.

Is cauliflower crust pizza healthier?

Not always. Per whole pizza, Caulipower's Margherita has the least sodium and saturated fat in our list. But the whole pizza still has 740 calories. It also has less fiber and protein than a chickpea crust like Banza.

Why is there BHA in frozen pepperoni pizza?

BHA and BHT are preservatives that keep the fat in pepperoni from going rancid. At high doses, BHA caused tumors in part of the stomach in rats and hamsters. In 2026, the FDA started a new safety review. Cheese and veggie pizzas usually don't contain it.

How can I make frozen pizza healthier?

Add spinach, peppers or mushrooms before baking. Eat one or two servings, not the whole pizza, and have a salad first. Pick a cheese or veggie pizza with about 700 mg of sodium or less per serving.