Is Bone Broth Healthy? Protein, Sodium, Lead and 8 Brands
Is bone broth healthy? Protein and sodium per cup, what studies say about gut, joints and skin, the lead question, and 8 store brands compared.

Bone broth went from grandma’s kitchen to coffee-shop menus. People sip it for protein, for their gut, their joints and their skin. But is bone broth healthy, or just expensive soup?
The short answer: bone broth is a healthy, low-calorie drink for most people. A cup of store-bought chicken bone broth has about 40–50 calories and 9–10 g of protein. That’s far more protein than regular broth. But the big claims about the gut, joints and skin are not proven for bone broth. Those studies used collagen supplements. Sodium ranges from about 230 to 380 mg per cup. A few brands also add flavorings and yeast extract. There’s a small question about lead, too.
What’s in a cup of bone broth
Bone broth is made by simmering animal bones in water for many hours. The long cooking breaks down collagen (the main protein in bones, skin and joints). Cooked collagen turns into gelatin. That’s why good broth jiggles when it’s cold.
Here is how it compares with regular chicken broth, per cup (8 oz / 240 ml):
| Per cup | Calories | Protein | Sodium |
|---|---|---|---|
| Chicken bone broth (Kettle & Fire) | 45 | 10 g | 330 mg |
| Regular chicken broth | 15 | 1.6 g | 924 mg |
| Reduced-sodium chicken broth | 17 | 3.3 g | 554 mg |
Bone broth: Open Food Facts. Regular broths: USDA FoodData Central – ready-to-serve and reduced sodium. Values per 100 g, multiplied to one cup and rounded.
What stands out:
- Protein: bone broth has about 6 times more protein than regular broth.
- Calories: it’s still very light. Ten grams of protein for 45 calories is a good deal.
- Sodium: many bone broths have less salt than regular broth. But it depends on the brand.
- Fat and carbs: almost zero in most cartons.
There is one catch. Collagen is an incomplete protein. It lacks tryptophan, one of the amino acids your body can’t make (Paul et al., Nutrients, 2019). So bone broth can add to your protein for the day. But it can’t replace eggs, fish, meat, beans or dairy. See our list of high-protein foods for better main sources.
Bone broth is also not a big source of minerals. A lab study in Taiwan tested homemade and store-bought broths. Each serving had less than 5% of the daily need for calcium and magnesium (Hsu et al., Food & Nutrition Research, 2017).
Gut, joints and skin: claims vs evidence
Bone broth is sold as a fix for many things. Here is what research actually shows.
Gut health
You’ll often read that bone broth “heals a leaky gut”. We found no good human trials on this.
There is one animal study. Mice drank beef bone broth freely for 10 days. Then researchers gave them a chemical that causes colitis (gut inflammation). The mice that had broth showed less damage in the colon. They also had lower signs of inflammation (Mar-Solís et al., Medicina, 2021).
Why do animal studies matter? Mice share most of our genes and body processes. And giving people a chemical that harms the gut would put their health at risk. Still, one mouse study is only a hint. Proof in humans is missing. Fermented foods like sauerkraut have more human research on the gut.
Joints
Collagen pills and powders have some support for joints.
- Athletes. 147 college athletes with joint pain took part. Half drank 10 g of collagen hydrolysate (broken-down collagen) a day for 24 weeks. The other half got a fake drink. The collagen group had a bit less joint pain (Clark et al., Current Medical Research and Opinion, 2008). Only 97 people finished, though.
- Arthritis. A review pooled trials in people with osteoarthritis (wear-and-tear arthritis). Collagen supplements improved overall symptom scores and stiffness. Results on pain were mixed. One pain scale improved, but the pain part of the main score did not (García-Coronado et al., International Orthopaedics, 2019).
Skin
- A review looked at 19 trials with 1,125 people, mostly women aged 20–70. Taking collagen supplements for about 90 days improved skin moisture, stretch (elasticity) and wrinkles (de Miranda et al., International Journal of Dermatology, 2021).
- A larger review of 26 trials also found better skin moisture and stretch. But it found several sources of bias in the trials (Pu et al., Nutrients, 2023).
Why broth isn’t the same as a supplement
All these trials used measured doses of collagen powder. Bone broth isn’t measured.
Australian researchers tested bone broths from stores, cafés and home recipes. They looked at the building blocks of collagen, like glycine and proline. Broth made to a standard recipe had less of them than a 20 g collagen supplement dose. Store-bought broths were lower than homemade ones. And amounts varied a lot between recipes (Alcock et al., International Journal of Sport Nutrition and Exercise Metabolism, 2019).
So if collagen helps joints or skin, a mug of broth may not give you the same dose.
Is there lead in bone broth?
Bones store lead from the environment. So some people worry that long cooking pulls it into the broth.
- A small UK study. Researchers tested three kinds of organic chicken broth. Broth made from bones had about 7 micrograms of lead per liter. Broth from skin and cartilage had 9.5. The tap water they started with, cooked the same way, had under 1 (Monro et al., Medical Hypotheses, 2013). That’s several times more lead than the water. But it was a tiny study of just three broths.
- A Taiwan study. It tested different bones, cooking times and broths. Lead and cadmium were only a few micrograms per serving. The authors called the risk minimal (Hsu et al., Food & Nutrition Research, 2017).
How big is that? At 7 micrograms per liter, a cup has about 1.7 micrograms of lead. The FDA set a daily reference level for lead from food. It is 2.2 micrograms for children and 8.8 micrograms for women who could get pregnant (FDA). So for a young child, one cup of that broth would use up most of the daily level. No amount of lead is known to be safe.
Keep in mind that the UK study tested only three broths. Store-bought brands rarely publish lead tests. For adults, a cup now and then is not a worry. But if you drink several cups a day, or give it to young kids often, it makes sense to vary your foods.
Bone broth vs broth vs stock
The names overlap, and brands use them in different ways. Regular broth is usually cooked for a shorter time and is thin. Stock and bone broth are made with bones and simmered longer, so they have more gelatin.
The label tells you more than the name. Check the protein line. Most bone broths have 9–10 g per cup. Regular broth has only about 1–3 g.
8 store-bought bone broths compared
Here are 8 chicken bone broths sold in the US. Values are per serving, as shown on the label.
| Product | Serving | Calories | Protein | Sodium | Flavor additives |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Kettle & Fire Classic Chicken | 1 cup | 45 | 10 g | 330 mg | None |
| Pacific Foods Organic Salted Chicken | 1 cup | 50 | 10 g | 300 mg | None |
| Swanson Sipping Chicken | 10.75 oz cup | 50 | 10 g | 460 mg | Yeast extract, natural flavoring |
| Kitchen Basics Original Chicken | 1 cup | 45 | 10 g | about 380 mg | None |
| Bonafide Provisions Organic Chicken | 16.9 oz carton | 80 | 18 g | 730 mg | None |
| Imagine Chicken | 1 cup | 40 | 9 g | 300 mg | Organic chicken flavor |
| Trader Joe’s Organic Chicken | 1 cup | 45 | 10 g | 280 mg | None |
| Simple Truth Organic Chicken | 1 cup | 40 | 9 g | 230 mg | Organic chicken flavor, yeast extract, organic flavor, cane sugar |
Sources: brand sites for Pacific Foods, Swanson and Imagine; Open Food Facts for Kettle & Fire, Kitchen Basics, Bonafide, Trader Joe’s and Simple Truth. Checked November 2026. Imagine’s nutrition table shows 0 g of protein, but its product text says 9 g. Recipes change – always check the carton.
What to notice:
- Protein is almost the same. Most brands land at 9–10 g per cup.
- Watch the serving size. Swanson’s cup is 10.75 oz (318 ml), about a third more than a cup. Bonafide’s whole 16.9 oz (500 ml) carton is one serving – about 2 cups. Per cup, Swanson has about 7.5 g of protein and 340 mg of sodium. Bonafide has about 8.5 g of protein and 345 mg of sodium.
- Sodium varies. Simple Truth and Trader Joe’s are lowest per cup. Kitchen Basics is highest per cup, at about 380 mg. Pacific Foods also sells an unsalted bone broth with 210 mg per cup (brand site).
- Most have short lists. Bones, water, vegetables, herbs and salt. Swanson, Imagine and Simple Truth add flavorings. Swanson and Simple Truth also add yeast extract.
Yeast extract and natural flavors
Yeast extract is made by breaking open yeast cells. It’s rich in free glutamate, the same savory compound as in MSG. It adds a strong savory, meaty taste.
In people, the proof of harm is weak. In one trial, 130 people who believed they reacted to MSG got 5 g of MSG or a fake dose. Some had more symptoms with MSG. But the reactions often didn’t come back when people were tested again. None were serious (Geha et al., Journal of Allergy and Clinical Immunology, 2000). Animal studies are more worrying. A 2023 review looked at studies in mice. Animals given MSG, often at high doses, had nerve cell damage and short-term memory problems (Ankul et al., Frontiers in Pharmacology, 2023). Proof of harm in people is missing. But since several labs see similar signs, it’s fair to limit flavor boosters as a precaution.
Natural flavors are flavorings made from a natural source, like chicken or spices. One “flavor” can be a mix of many substances. They aren’t known to be harmful in small amounts. But they’re a sign of a more processed product. Broths without them simply taste like what’s in them.
Who should be careful
- People on a low-sodium diet. The daily value for sodium is 2,300 mg. Two cups of a saltier brand use up about a third of that. Pick an unsalted or low-sodium version.
- People with kidney disease. Ask your doctor about salt and protein limits first.
- Young kids and pregnant women. Because of the lead question, don’t make it a daily habit. Keep it as one food among many.
- Anyone using it as a meal. A cup of broth has only 40–50 calories. It won’t keep you full for long on its own.
How to use bone broth well:
- Sip it as a snack. It’s warm, light and adds protein. See more ideas in our guide to high-protein snacks.
- Cook with it. Use it in place of water for rice, soups or stews. Or try a homemade pho.
- Check the label for sodium, protein and a short ingredient list.
- Count it toward your protein, but not as your main source. Find your target with our protein calculator.
Check the label on your bone broth. With NutriSmart, you photograph the label or scan the barcode. The app lists the sweeteners, preservatives and colors, explains the risks of each one and gives the product a health score out of 100. It also tells you right away if a broth is ultra-processed and which ingredients make it so. Set an alert for yeast extract, and the app warns you whenever a product you scan contains it.Get the app free
The bottom line
Bone broth is a healthy, low-calorie drink for most people. A cup has about 40–50 calories and 9–10 g of protein – far more than regular broth. But that protein is mostly collagen, which isn’t a complete protein. The gut, joint and skin claims come from collagen supplements and one mouse study, not from broth itself. Lead levels look low, but the research is small, so don’t overdo it. Pick a brand with a short ingredient list and moderate sodium. Enjoy it as a warm, protein-rich extra – not a cure.
FAQ
Is bone broth healthy?
Yes, for most people it's a healthy, low-calorie drink. A cup of store-bought chicken bone broth has about 40–50 calories and 9–10 g of protein. Claims about gut, joints and skin are not proven for bone broth itself.
How much protein is in bone broth?
Most store brands list 9–10 g of protein per cup. Regular chicken broth has only about 1.6 g. Most of the protein in bone broth comes from collagen, which lacks one essential amino acid.
Does bone broth help your gut?
There are no good human studies on bone broth and gut health. One mouse study found less gut inflammation after the mice drank bone broth. That's a hint, not proof.
Is drinking bone broth as good as taking collagen?
Not really. The skin and joint studies used collagen supplements at a set dose. A lab test found that bone broth gave much less of collagen's building blocks than a 20 g supplement dose, and the amounts varied a lot.
Is there lead in bone broth?
Small amounts can get into broth, because bones store lead. One small study found a few times more lead than in the water used. Another found only a few micrograms per serving, which it called a minimal risk.
Is bone broth high in sodium?
It depends on the brand. The store brands in our table have about 230–380 mg per cup. That's much less than regular chicken broth, which has over 900 mg per cup.


