Healthiest Protein Shakes: 12 Ready-to-Drink Shakes Compared
The healthiest protein shakes compared: Premier, Core Power, Orgain, OWYN, Slate, Iconic and more by protein, sugar, sweeteners, gums and price per bottle.

Ready-to-drink protein shakes fill a whole fridge at the store now. They all promise lots of protein and little sugar. So which ones are the healthiest protein shakes?
The short answer: the healthiest shakes have 20–30 g of protein, 5 g of added sugar or less, and a short ingredient list without artificial sweeteners or carrageenan. Of the 12 shakes we checked, Orgain’s 30 g shake, Slate, Iconic and Chobani’s 20 g protein drink come closest. Premier Protein, Core Power and Ensure Max Protein have great numbers. But they use sucralose, acesulfame K and carrageenan. For most people, one shake a day is plenty. Real food should do most of the work.
What makes a protein shake healthy
Most shakes look alike on the front. The back of the bottle tells you more. Check these five things:
- Protein: 20–30 g. That’s enough for a filling snack or after a workout. More isn’t always better.
- Added sugar: 5 g or less. Milk has natural sugar (lactose). So a shake made from real milk can show more total sugar with 0 g added. Check the “added sugars” line.
- Sweeteners. Sucralose and acesulfame K (ace-K) are artificial. Stevia and monk fruit come from plants.
- Thickeners. Carrageenan and cellulose gum keep shakes smooth. Both have raised questions in studies (more below).
- Price. Shakes cost about $2–5 per bottle. That adds up if you drink one every day.
26–30 g milk protein shakes compared
These are the big, high-protein shakes. All are made with milk protein.
| Shake (size) | Calories | Protein | Sugar | Sweeteners | Thickeners | Price per bottle |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Premier Protein Chocolate (11 oz) | 160 | 30 g | 1 g | Sucralose, ace‑K | Carrageenan, cellulose gum | about $2.40 |
| Ensure Max Protein Milk Chocolate (11 oz) | 150 | 30 g | 1 g | Sucralose, ace‑K | Carrageenan, cellulose gum | about $2.55 |
| fairlife Core Power Chocolate 26g (14 oz) | 170 | 26 g | 5 g (0 g added) | Sucralose, ace-K, monk fruit, stevia | Carrageenan, cellulose gum | about $3.99 |
| Muscle Milk Genuine Chocolate (11 oz) | 160 | 26 g | 0 g added | Stevia | Carrageenan, cellulose gel and gum* | about $2.33 |
| Quest Chocolate (11 oz) | 170 | 30 g | 1 g (0 g added) | Sucralose, stevia | Gellan gum | about $2.22 |
| Orgain 30g Chocolate Fudge (11 oz) | 160 | 30 g | 1 g (0 g added) | Monk fruit, stevia | Gellan gum, cellulose gum | about $2.50 |
Labels: Premier Protein and Open Food Facts; Ensure Max Protein brand page, ingredients from Open Food Facts (flavor not shown); fairlife Core Power; Muscle Milk; Quest from Open Food Facts (2023 label); Orgain from Open Food Facts. Prices checked November 2026 at Target (Premier, Ensure, Quest 4-packs; Core Power single bottle; Orgain 12-pack) and on gatorade.com (Muscle Milk 24-pack). *The Muscle Milk site doesn’t show total sugar or the full ingredient list. The thickeners come from the 14 oz chocolate bottle of the same 26 g shake on Open Food Facts.
What stands out:
- Premier and Ensure Max Protein are almost twins. Same protein, same two artificial sweeteners, both with carrageenan. Some Ensure Max Protein flavors also have caffeine. The Café Mocha label lists 100 mg, about a cup of coffee. Read more in is Premier Protein healthy.
- Core Power is made from filtered milk, so it’s closer to real milk. But it uses four sweeteners, including sucralose and ace-K, plus carrageenan. See whether fairlife milk is healthy.
- Quest skips carrageenan. But it uses sucralose, plus a little stevia.
- Orgain 30 g has the same protein as Premier, with no artificial sweeteners and no carrageenan.
- Muscle Milk now uses stevia instead of artificial sweeteners. But the bottle still lists carrageenan and cellulose gum.
Lighter and plant-based shakes compared
These shakes have less protein, cleaner labels or plant protein. Huel Black is a meal, not a snack.
| Shake (size) | Calories | Protein | Sugar | Sweeteners | Thickeners | Price per bottle |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Slate Classic Chocolate (11 oz can) | 100 | 20 g | 1 g (0 g added) | Monk fruit, stevia | Cellulose gel and gum, pectin | about $3.33 |
| Iconic Chocolate Truffle (1 bottle) | 140 | 20 g | 0 g | Monk fruit, stevia | Locust bean gum, gellan gum | about $4.17 |
| Chobani 20g Protein Cookies & Cream (10 oz) | 160 | 20 g | 11 g (0 g added) | Monk fruit, stevia | Pectin, locust bean gum | about $2.99 |
| Orgain Clean Protein Chocolate (11 oz) | 130 | 20 g | 3 g | Organic agave* | Cellulose (no carrageenan) | about $3.00 |
| OWYN 20g Dark Chocolate, plant (11.15 oz) | 180 | 20 g | 4 g (4 g added) | Cane sugar, monk fruit | Guar gum, gellan gum | about $2.17 |
| Huel Black Chocolate, plant (16.9 oz) | 400 | 35 g | about 4 g | Coconut sugar, stevia | Gellan gum | about $4.83 |
Labels: Slate; Iconic; Chobani from Open Food Facts; Orgain Clean from the brand page and Open Food Facts; OWYN from Open Food Facts (an older 12 oz label; the 11.15 oz bottles list the same numbers); Huel from huel.com and Open Food Facts. Prices checked November 2026 on brand sites (12-packs; Huel with subscription) and at Target (Chobani single, OWYN 4-pack). *From a 2023 label on Open Food Facts. The brand site says it has no artificial sweeteners but doesn’t list ingredients.
What stands out:
- Slate has the fewest calories – 100 for 20 g of protein – and no carrageenan.
- Iconic has zero sugar and no artificial sweeteners. At about $4.17, it is one of the priciest snack shakes.
- Chobani’s drink is made from cultured milk (like a thin yogurt). Its 11 g of sugar is natural milk sugar, not added.
- OWYN is the plant pick for a snack. It has pea and pumpkin seed protein, but 4 g of added sugar.
- Huel Black has 400 calories. Drink it instead of a meal, not on top of one.
Our picks by goal
- Best all-round: Orgain 30 g. Lots of protein, 1 g of sugar, no artificial sweeteners, no carrageenan.
- Fewest calories: Slate (100 calories).
- Closest to real food: Chobani’s 20 g protein drink, made from cultured milk.
- Dairy-free snack: OWYN 20 g.
- Dairy-free meal: Huel Black.
- Lowest price: OWYN 20 g (about $2.17). Quest, Muscle Milk and Premier Protein cost about $2.22–2.40. Our all-round pick, Orgain 30 g, is only a little more, at about $2.50.
Prefer to mix your own? See our guide to the healthiest protein powder.
Sweeteners: what studies show
The FDA allows sucralose and ace-K. But independent labs keep finding warning signs:
- Sucralose in mice. Male mice drank sucralose for 6 months. The dose matched the human safe daily limit. Their gut bacteria changed. Their livers showed more signs of inflammation (Bian et al., Frontiers in Physiology, 2017).
- Sucralose for life. Mice got sucralose in their food from before birth until death. More males got blood cancers. The rise was clearest at 2,000 ppm (0.2% of their food) and at the highest dose. These doses are much higher than what people get from food (Soffritti et al., International Journal of Occupational and Environmental Health, 2016).
- Ace-K in mice. Mice got acesulfame K for 4 weeks. Their gut bacteria changed, and the males gained more weight (Bian et al., PLOS ONE, 2017).
- Sucralose in people. A trial had 120 healthy adults. Some took sucralose packets for 2 weeks, below the safe daily limit. Their blood sugar rose more after a sugar drink. The effect varied a lot from person to person (Suez et al., Cell, 2022).
- A large French study. It followed 103,388 adults for years. People who had more ace-K or sucralose had a higher risk of heart disease (Debras et al., BMJ, 2022). This shows a link, not proof.
Why do mouse studies matter? Mice share most of our genes and body processes. And testing a possibly harmful dose on people for years would put their health at risk. Still, human proof of harm is missing. Several labs see similar signals, so it’s wise to limit these sweeteners as a precaution.
Stevia and monk fruit come from plants. They have fewer long-term studies, so we know less about them – good or bad. So far, they have raised fewer warning signs.
Carrageenan and cellulose gum
Shakes need thickeners, or the protein settles at the bottom. Two of them have mixed research.
Carrageenan comes from red seaweed.
- Mice got a small amount (10 mg per liter) in their drinking water. They got worse at handling sugar. Insulin (the hormone that moves sugar into cells) worked less well (Bhattacharyya et al., Diabetologia, 2012).
- 20 young men took 250 mg of carrageenan twice a day for 2 weeks. Overall, there was no clear change. But in the men with extra weight, insulin worked less well. They also had more signs of inflammation (Wagner et al., BMC Medicine, 2024).
Cellulose gum is also called carboxymethylcellulose (CMC).
- Mice got CMC in their drinking water. They developed mild gut inflammation and gained weight. Mice prone to bowel disease got colitis (an inflamed colon) (Chassaing et al., Nature, 2015).
- In a small trial, 7 healthy adults ate 15 g of CMC a day for 11 days. 9 others ate the same diet without it. The CMC group had a bit more belly discomfort. Their gut bacteria became less varied (Chassaing et al., Gastroenterology, 2022). That’s far more CMC than one shake has.
These studies are small. But if you have a bowel disease or blood sugar problems, pick a shake without carrageenan or cellulose gum.
Who needs protein shakes
Most people can get enough protein from food. A shake helps most if you:
- Lift weights and fall short on protein. A review of 49 trials found extra protein helped muscle growth. But the gains stopped at about 1.6 g per kg of body weight a day (0.7 g per pound) (Morton et al., British Journal of Sports Medicine, 2018).
- Are over 65. Experts advise at least 1.0–1.2 g per kg a day to keep muscle (Bauer et al., Journal of the American Medical Directors Association, 2013). A shake can help if your appetite is small.
- Are cutting calories and want a filling snack.
- Need a fast option on busy days, instead of a pastry.
Not sure what you need? Try our protein calculator.
Be careful or skip shakes if you: have kidney disease (ask your doctor first), have a milk allergy (pick a plant shake), or are a child. Kids rarely need protein shakes.
Whole-food alternatives
You can make a shake at home in one minute. Blend:
- 1 cup (8 oz / 245 g) skim milk
- 6 oz (170 g) plain nonfat Greek yogurt
- 1 tablespoon unsweetened cocoa
You get about 195 calories and 27 g of protein. The 18 g of sugar is natural sugar from milk and yogurt. There are no sweeteners and no gums. Add half a banana if you want it sweeter. (Numbers from USDA FoodData Central: skim milk, nonfat Greek yogurt, cocoa.) For fruit-based blends, see are smoothies healthy?
No time to blend? Eggs, cottage cheese, tuna and Greek yogurt are all easy protein. See our list of high-protein snacks for more ideas.
Check your protein shake before you buy. With NutriSmart, you photograph the label or scan the barcode. The app lists the sweeteners, preservatives and colors, explains the risks of each one and gives the product a health score out of 100. It also tells you right away if a shake is ultra-processed and which ingredients make it so. Set an alert for sucralose or carrageenan. The app then warns you every time a product you scan contains it.Get the app free
The bottom line
The healthiest protein shakes give you 20–30 g of protein with little added sugar and a short ingredient list. Orgain 30 g, Slate, Iconic and Chobani’s 20 g drink skip artificial sweeteners and carrageenan. Premier Protein, Ensure Max Protein and Core Power have great numbers. But they rely on sucralose, ace-K and carrageenan, which have open questions in studies. Human proof of harm is still missing. So if you drink these, keep it to one a day. Most people don’t need shakes at all. Milk, yogurt, eggs and a quick homemade shake do the same job.
FAQ
What is the healthiest protein shake to buy?
Look for 20–30 g of protein, 5 g of added sugar or less, no artificial sweeteners and no carrageenan. Orgain's 30 g shake, Slate, Iconic and Chobani's 20 g drink fit those rules. Premier Protein and Ensure Max Protein have good numbers but use sucralose, acesulfame K and carrageenan.
Are protein shakes good for you?
They are a handy way to get more protein, but they are not a health food. Most are ultra-processed, with sweeteners and thickeners. One shake a day is fine for most healthy adults. Get the rest of your protein from real food.
Which protein shake has no artificial sweeteners?
Orgain 30 g, Slate, Iconic, Chobani's 20 g protein drink and Muscle Milk use stevia and/or monk fruit instead. OWYN uses cane sugar and monk fruit. Huel Black uses coconut sugar and stevia.
What is the best plant-based protein shake?
OWYN 20 g has pea and pumpkin seed protein, 180 calories and 4 g of added sugar. Huel Black has 35 g of pea and faba bean protein, but 400 calories, so it works as a meal, not a snack.
Is it OK to drink a protein shake every day?
For most healthy adults, yes – one a day is fine. If you drink two or more, the sweeteners and gums add up. People with kidney disease should ask their doctor about extra protein first.
Can I make a healthy protein shake at home?
Yes. Blend 1 cup of skim milk, 6 oz of plain nonfat Greek yogurt and 1 tablespoon of cocoa. You get about 27 g of protein and 195 calories, with no added sugar, sweeteners or gums.


