Is Kefir Healthy? Probiotics, Sugar and 9 Kefirs Compared

Is kefir healthy? Protein, calcium and sugar per cup, what studies really show on gut health and lactose, plus plain vs flavored and 9 kefirs compared.

By NutriSmart Team10 min read

The title Is Kefir Healthy? above a tall glass of thick white kefir and a white bottle labeled KEFIR with a green leaf, with fresh raspberries at their base

Kefir is a tangy, drinkable cousin of yogurt. It sits next to the milk in most US stores. But is it as good for you as the bottle says?

The short answer: yes – plain kefir is one of the healthiest drinks in the dairy aisle. A cup of plain low-fat kefir has about 110 calories, 10 g of protein and about 30% of your daily calcium. It also has live cultures – Lifeway lists 12. Many people with lactose intolerance handle it better than milk. But the big health claims go further than the science. Human studies are small. So far, trials found no clear drop in cholesterol or blood pressure. Flavored kefir can also have 8 g of added sugar per cup. Choose plain, and add your own fruit.

Kefir nutrition per cup

Here is how one cup (8 oz / 240 ml) of plain kefir compares with milk and yogurt. The numbers are from the USDA food database.

Per 1 cup Calories Protein Fat Sugar Calcium
Kefir, low-fat plain 104 9.2 g 2.5 g 11.2 g 316 mg
2% milk 122 8.1 g 4.8 g 12.3 g 293 mg
Plain low-fat yogurt 154 12.9 g 3.8 g 17.2 g 448 mg

Source: USDA FoodData Central – kefir, low-fat plain, 2% milk, plain low-fat yogurt. Values per 100 g, multiplied to one cup and rounded. The kefir entry is an older Lifeway sample. Today’s Lifeway label shows 110 calories, 10 g of protein and 9 g of sugar.

What stands out:

  • Protein: kefir has about as much as milk.
  • Sugar: in plain kefir, it’s all natural milk sugar (lactose). None is added.
  • Calcium: the Lifeway label lists 390 mg, or 30% of the daily value. Lifeway also adds vitamin D – 3.8 mcg, or 20%.
  • Vitamin B12: a cup has about 0.7 mcg. That’s about 30% of what adults need each day. B12 helps make red blood cells.

So plain kefir is a lot like milk, plus live cultures. For more choices, see the healthiest milk.

What makes kefir different from yogurt

Both are fermented milk: tiny living things eat some milk sugar and turn it sour. But kefir uses different cultures than yogurt (Hertzler and Clancy, Journal of the American Dietetic Association, 2003).

Traditional kefir is made with kefir grains. These are not real grains. They are soft clumps of bacteria and yeasts that look a bit like cauliflower. The yeasts make kefir a little fizzy.

Most brands list their cultures on the label. Trader Joe’s plain kefir lists 12, including a yeast called S. florentinus (Open Food Facts). Lifeway says its kefir has 12 live and active cultures too. Redwood Hill’s goat milk kefir lists 10.

A longer list doesn’t by itself mean a healthier drink.

Kefir and lactose intolerance

At Ohio State University, researchers tested 15 adults who had trouble digesting lactose. Each test meal had the same amount of lactose – 20 g. They got milk, kefir or yogurt. The team measured hydrogen in the breath. This gas shows up when lactose isn’t digested well.

Here is what they found:

  • Plain kefir caused about 60% less breath hydrogen than milk.
  • Flavored kefir did better than milk, but not as well as plain.
  • With kefir or yogurt, people rated their gas 54–71% less severe than with milk.

(Hertzler and Clancy, Journal of the American Dietetic Association, 2003)

So the cultures seem to help digest the lactose. It’s a small study, though, and each test was a single meal.

Some kefirs go further. Lifeway’s whole milk plain kefir adds the lactase enzyme (the enzyme that breaks down lactose). The company sells it as lactose-free (Lifeway). Its low-fat plain kefir has no added lactase. Lifeway calls it “lactose intolerance friendly”.

What studies show about kefir’s health benefits

Gut health

A 2026 review looked at 8 human studies on kefir and gut bacteria. The changes were small and not the same from study to study. But Bifidobacterium, a type of helpful gut bacteria, went up in 3 of 4 studies that tracked it (Hamsho et al., MicrobiologyOpen, 2026).

In Turkey, 20 adults with constipation drank about 2 cups (500 ml) of kefir a day for 4 weeks. They went to the bathroom more often and used fewer laxatives (Turan et al., Turkish Journal of Gastroenterology, 2014). But there was no comparison group.

At Stanford, 36 healthy adults ate more fiber or more fermented foods for 17 weeks. The fermented foods included yogurt, kefir and kimchi. The fermented-food group had more kinds of gut bacteria and lower signs of inflammation (the body’s alarm response) (Wastyk et al., Cell, 2021). This study did not test kefir alone.

Kefir doesn’t always help. In a US trial, 125 children aged 1 to 5 took antibiotics. Some also drank kefir. Others got a look-alike drink with the cultures killed by heat. Diarrhea was about the same: 18% vs 22% (Merenstein et al., Archives of Pediatrics and Adolescent Medicine, 2009).

Cholesterol and blood sugar

In Canada, 13 men with slightly high cholesterol drank kefir or milk for 4 weeks each. Kefir did not lower cholesterol more than milk (St-Onge et al., BMC Complementary and Alternative Medicine, 2002).

A 2023 review pooled 6 trials. Kefir had no effect on cholesterol, triglycerides (blood fats), blood sugar or weight. But it did lower fasting insulin and insulin resistance (when the body stops responding well to insulin) (Yahyapoor et al., Current Drug Targets, 2023).

In Iran, 60 adults with type 2 diabetes drank about 2.5 cups (600 ml) a day for 8 weeks. Some had a probiotic kefir drink. Others had a plain fermented milk drink. In the kefir group, fasting blood sugar and HbA1c (a 3-month blood sugar test) dropped more. Cholesterol didn’t change (Ostadrahimi et al., Iranian Journal of Public Health, 2015).

Blood pressure

A 2025 review pooled 7 trials with 385 adults. Kefir did not lower blood pressure in a clear way. A marker of inflammation called CRP fell only in trials that lasted 8 weeks or more (Rashidbeygi et al., Endocrinology, Diabetes and Metabolism, 2025).

The big picture

A 2023 review of kefir trials found 16 studies. 12 of them had a high risk of bias – flaws that can skew results. The authors said kefir seems safe for healthy people. But they want better trials before making health claims (Kairey et al., Nutrition Reviews, 2023).

Plain vs flavored kefir: the sugar gap

Flavor changes kefir a lot. Here are two Lifeway low-fat kefirs, per cup:

  • Plain: 110 calories, 9 g of sugar, 0 g added.
  • Strawberry: 140 calories, 18 g of sugar, 8 g added.

The 8 g of added sugar is about 2 teaspoons. That’s 16% of the 50 g daily value on US labels. Cane sugar is the second ingredient, right after milk. The strawberry kefir also has natural flavors and vegetable juice for color (Lifeway).

Plain is the better pick. You can add fresh berries yourself. You get the fruit’s fiber and no added sugar.

9 kefirs compared

Here are 9 real products sold in the US. Values are per 1 cup (8 oz / 240 ml), except the GT’s can (12 oz / 355 ml).

Product Calories Protein Sugar (added) Calcium Notes
Lifeway Lowfat Plain 110 10 g 9 g (0 g) 390 mg 12 cultures, added vitamin D
Lifeway Lowfat Strawberry 140 10 g 18 g (8 g) 390 mg Cane sugar, natural flavors
Lifeway Whole Milk Plain 150 10 g 10 g (0 g) 390 mg Lactose‑free (added lactase)
Maple Hill Plain (grass-fed whole milk) about 180 about 7.5 g about 12 g (0 g) about 300 mg Just milk and cultures
Redwood Hill Farm Plain (goat milk) 140 8 g 5 g (0 g) 350 mg Just goat milk and 10 cultures
Trader Joe’s Low Fat Plain 90 9 g 8 g (0 g) about 340 mg 12 cultures listed
Friendly Farms (Aldi) Lowfat Plain 100 10 g 9 g (0 g) about 290 mg Store brand
Forager Project Unsweetened Plain (cashew and coconut) 140 4 g 1 g (0 g) 24 mg Dairy‑free, 9 cultures
GT’s Agua de Kefir Guava Paloma (water kefir, 12 oz can) 20 0 g 5 g (2 g) 15 mg Cane sugar, erythritol, stevia

Sources: Lifeway product pages for Lowfat Plain, Lowfat Strawberry and Whole Milk Plain; Maple Hill label (per 2/3 cup, multiplied to one cup); Forager Project; Open Food Facts for Redwood Hill Farm, Trader Joe’s, Friendly Farms and GT’s. Checked November 2026. Recipes change – always check the bottle.

What to notice:

  • Plain dairy kefirs are all close: about 90–180 calories, 7.5–10 g of protein and no added sugar.
  • Maple Hill has the most calories, because it’s whole milk. Its label also shows less protein per cup than Lifeway.
  • Redwood Hill has the least sugar of the dairy kefirs. It’s a good pick if you’d like goat milk instead of cow’s milk.
  • Trader Joe’s and Aldi store brands are almost the same as Lifeway Lowfat Plain.
  • Forager has little protein and almost no calcium. GT’s has no protein and very little calcium.

Water kefir and dairy-free kefir

Water kefir is sugar water or juice fermented with water kefir grains. It’s light and fizzy. It has live cultures, but almost no protein or calcium. It’s closer to kombucha than to milk kefir.

GT’s Agua de Kefir has only 20 calories per can. It has 2 g of added cane sugar. The rest of its sweet taste comes from erythritol and stevia. The can doesn’t say how much erythritol it has.

Erythritol has some warning signs. A Cleveland Clinic team measured it in the blood of over 4,000 people. Those with the most had about 1.8 to 2.2 times the risk of a heart attack, stroke or death over three years. In the same study, erythritol made blood clot faster in mice (Witkowski et al., Nature Medicine, 2023). In a follow-up, 10 healthy people drank 30 g of erythritol, an amount the researchers called typical. Their blood platelets (cells that help form clots) became more active. Glucose didn’t do this (Witkowski et al., Arteriosclerosis, Thrombosis, and Vascular Biology, 2024).

Why do mouse studies matter? Mice share most of our genes and body processes. And testing possible harm on people would put their health at risk. Most of this work comes from one research team. Proof of harm from small amounts is still missing. But the same warning sign shows up in mice and in people. So it’s wise to limit erythritol as a precaution.

Dairy-free kefir is usually made from nuts or coconut. Forager’s unsweetened plain has no added sugar and 9 cultures. But it has only 4 g of protein and 24 mg of calcium per cup. It also has 2.5 g of saturated fat. If you skip dairy, get your calcium from other foods.

Who should be careful with kefir

  • People with a milk allergy. Dairy kefir is still milk. Lactose-free kefir is too.
  • People with a weak immune system. Kefir is full of live microbes. The 2023 review found that only 5 of 18 trial reports checked safety. Ask your doctor first.
  • People watching calories. Whole milk kefir has 150–180 calories per cup. Use our calorie calculator to see your daily needs.
  • Anyone new to kefir. Start with half a cup and see how your stomach feels.

How to drink kefir

  1. Buy plain. Look for 0 g added sugar on the label.
  2. Check for “live and active cultures” on the bottle.
  3. Add your own flavor. Blend it with berries in a smoothie.
  4. Pour it on cereal or oats instead of milk.
  5. Use it like buttermilk in a creamy salad dressing.
  6. Keep it cold. Heat kills the live cultures, so add it to food after cooking.
  7. Count the protein. A cup gives about 10 g. Check your daily target with our protein calculator.

For more protein, see the healthiest yogurt and cottage cheese. For a fermented food with fiber, try sauerkraut.

Check your kefir before you buy. With NutriSmart, you photograph the label or scan the barcode. The app lists the sweeteners, preservatives and colors, explains the risks of each one and gives the product a health score out of 100. It also tells you right away if a kefir is ultra-processed, and which ingredients make it so. Set an alert for erythritol, and the app warns you whenever a bottle you scan contains it.Get the app free

The bottom line

Plain kefir is a healthy drink for most people. A cup has about 110 calories, 10 g of protein, lots of calcium and live cultures. It may help people with lactose intolerance digest milk sugar. Gut health results look promising, but the studies are small. Trials so far found no clear drop in cholesterol or blood pressure. Pick plain kefir with no added sugar, and add your own fruit. Water kefir and dairy-free kefir have live cultures, but not the protein and calcium of milk kefir.

FAQ

Is kefir healthy?

Plain kefir is a healthy drink for most people. A cup of low-fat plain kefir has about 110 calories, 10 g of protein, about 30% of your daily calcium and live cultures. Flavored kefir can have 8 g of added sugar per cup.

Is kefir better than yogurt?

Neither is clearly better. Kefir usually lists more live cultures, and some of them are yeasts. Plain yogurt has a bit more protein and calcium per cup. Pick the one you like, as long as it's plain.

Can I drink kefir if I'm lactose intolerant?

Many people can. In a small study, kefir caused much less gas than milk with the same amount of lactose. Some brands also add the lactase enzyme and sell lactose-free kefir.

How much kefir should I drink a day?

There's no official amount. Several studies used about 2 to 2.5 cups (500–600 ml) a day. One cup of plain kefir a day is a good place to start.

Does kefir have a lot of sugar?

Plain kefir has about 5–12 g of sugar per cup, and it's all natural milk sugar. Lifeway's strawberry kefir has 18 g, and 8 g of that is added. Check the added sugar line on the label.

Is water kefir as healthy as milk kefir?

Not in the same way. Water kefir has live cultures but almost no protein or calcium. Some brands also add cane sugar or sweeteners like erythritol.